P Probability — coverage pack

9 specification leaves · notes, questions, answers and worked methods

P1 · Record, describe and analyse the frequency of outcomes of probability experiments using tables and frequency trees

  • A frequency table records how often each outcome occurs; the frequencies should add to the total number of trials.
  • On a frequency tree, subtract from the parent frequency to complete a missing branch, then check that the two child branches add back to their parent.
  • For example, if 7070 trials split into frequencies 4343 and 2727, and 1818 of the first group succeed, the other frequency in that group is 4318=2543-18=25.
  • Do not put probabilities on a frequency tree when frequencies are requested, and do not compare raw frequencies when the group totals are different.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. A spinner is used 3030 times. It lands on red 1818 times and on blue 1212 times. Complete a frequency table for the two outcomes and work out the relative frequency of red.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • Red: 1818; blue: 1212.
    • Relative frequency of red =1830=0.6=\dfrac{18}{30}=0.6.

    Method: Record the observed counts in the table and check that 18+12=3018+12=30. Divide the red frequency by the total number of spins: 18÷30=0.618\div30=0.6.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. A frequency tree describes 8080 visits to a kiosk. On 5252 visits a hot drink is chosen and on the remaining visits a cold drink is chosen. A snack is also bought on 3131 hot-drink visits and on 77 cold-drink visits. Complete all terminal frequencies and work out the percentage of visits on which a snack is bought.[3 marks]

    Answer

    • Cold drink: 2828; hot drink and no snack: 2121; cold drink and no snack: 2121.
    • Snack percentage =47.5%=47.5\%.

    Method: The cold-drink branch has frequency 8052=2880-52=28. The no-snack frequencies are 5231=2152-31=21 and 287=2128-7=21. Snacks are bought on 31+7=3831+7=38 visits, so the percentage is 3880×100=47.5%\dfrac{38}{80}\times100=47.5\%.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. Two weeks of trials are combined. In week 1, 7272 of 120120 trials succeed; 4545 successful trials and 1818 unsuccessful trials are fast. In week 2, 9999 of 180180 trials succeed; 6666 successful trials and 2727 unsuccessful trials are fast. Construct a combined frequency table for success or failure against fast or not fast. Compare the proportions that are fast in the two outcome groups.[5 marks]

    Answer

    • Success: 111111 fast and 6060 not fast; failure: 4545 fast and 8484 not fast.
    • Proportion of successful trials that are fast =11117164.9%=\dfrac{111}{171}\approx64.9\%; proportion of failed trials that are fast =4512934.9%=\dfrac{45}{129}\approx34.9\%.
    • A successful trial is more likely to be fast.

    Method: Combine like branches: successful trials total 72+99=17172+99=171, of which 45+66=11145+66=111 are fast, so 6060 are not fast. Failures total (12072)+(18099)=129(120-72)+(180-99)=129, of which 18+27=4518+27=45 are fast, so 8484 are not fast. Compare within each outcome group: 111/1710.649111/171\approx0.649 and 45/1290.34945/129\approx0.349.

P2 · Apply ideas of randomness, fairness and equally likely events to calculate expected outcomes of multiple future experiments

  • Randomness means that an individual result is uncertain even when the long-run pattern can be predicted.
  • For equally likely outcomes, calculate an event probability by dividing favourable outcomes by total outcomes, then use expected frequency =n×p=n\times p for nn future trials.
  • A fair game gives participants equal chances or has zero expected gain after any cost; fairness must be justified from the probabilities and rewards.
  • An expected frequency is a long-run prediction, not a guarantee that exactly that many outcomes will occur.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. A fair six-sided die is rolled 240240 times. Work out the expected number of rolls on which the score is greater than 44.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • 8080 rolls

    Method: The favourable scores are 55 and 66, so the probability is 2/6=1/32/6=1/3. The expected frequency is 240×13=80240\times\dfrac{1}{3}=80.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. A fair spinner has four equal sectors labelled 11, 11, 22 and 33. It is spun 600600 times. Work out the expected total of all the scores.[3 marks]

    Answer

    • 10501050

    Method: The expected score per spin is 1+1+2+34=74\dfrac{1+1+2+3}{4}=\dfrac{7}{4}. Over 600600 spins, the expected total is 600×74=1050600\times\dfrac{7}{4}=1050.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. A box contains 33 green, 22 yellow and 11 red token. A token is chosen at random and replaced. A player receives £4\pounds4 for green, £1\pounds1 for yellow and nothing for red. The entry fee is £2.20\pounds2.20. Work out the organiser's expected profit from 900900 plays and decide whether the game is fair to the player.[5 marks]

    Answer

    • Expected payout per play =£73=\pounds\dfrac{7}{3}.
    • Expected organiser profit from 900900 plays =£120=-\pounds120.
    • The game is not fair; the player has an expected gain of about 13.313.3 pence per play.

    Method: The expected payout is 4×36+1×26=2+13=734\times\dfrac{3}{6}+1\times\dfrac{2}{6}=2+\dfrac{1}{3}=\dfrac{7}{3} pounds. The organiser receives £2.20=£115\pounds2.20=\pounds\dfrac{11}{5} per play, so expected profit per play is 11573=215\dfrac{11}{5}-\dfrac{7}{3}=-\dfrac{2}{15} pounds. Over 900900 plays this is 900×(2/15)=120900\times(-2/15)=-120 pounds. A fair entry fee would equal the expected payout, so this game favours the player.

P3 · Relate relative expected frequencies to theoretical probability, using appropriate language and the 0-1 probability scale

  • Probability lies from 00 to 11: 00 means impossible, 11 means certain, and values nearer 11 describe more likely events.
  • Relative frequency is observed frequency divided by number of trials; theoretical probability comes from a mathematical model of the outcomes.
  • If a theoretical probability is pp, the relative frequency from many unbiased trials is expected to be close to pp, although it will usually not equal it exactly.
  • Do not describe an event with probability 0.50.5 as certain, and do not treat a small experimental difference as proof that a theoretical model is wrong.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. Place these events in order from least likely to most likely: event A has probability 0.720.72, event B has probability 14\dfrac{1}{4}, and event C has probability 0.50.5.[1 mark]

    Answer

    • B, C, A

    Method: Write every probability as a decimal: 14=0.25\dfrac{1}{4}=0.25, then compare 0.25<0.5<0.720.25<0.5<0.72.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. An outcome occurs 8484 times in 140140 trials. Its theoretical probability is 58\dfrac{5}{8}. Work out the relative frequency and the expected frequency in 560560 further trials. Comment on the experimental result.[3 marks]

    Answer

    • Relative frequency =0.6=0.6.
    • Expected frequency =350=350.
    • 0.60.6 is reasonably close to the theoretical probability 0.6250.625.

    Method: The relative frequency is 84/140=0.684/140=0.6. The theoretical probability is 5/8=0.6255/8=0.625, so the expected frequency is 560×5/8=350560\times5/8=350. The observed value differs by only 0.0250.025, which is plausible experimental variation.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. A model says that a device flashes with probability 0.50.5 on each trial. In a short run it flashes 4141 times in 8080 trials. After 500500 trials in total it has flashed 247247 times. Calculate both relative frequencies and decide which result gives stronger evidence about the model.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • Short-run relative frequency =0.5125=0.5125.
    • Overall relative frequency =0.494=0.494.
    • The 500500-trial result gives stronger evidence and is very close to 0.50.5, so it supports the model.

    Method: For the short run, calculate 41/80=0.512541/80=0.5125. For all trials, calculate 247/500=0.494247/500=0.494. Both are close to 0.50.5, but the larger sample is less affected by random variation, so the overall relative frequency is the stronger comparison.

P4 · Apply the property that the probabilities of an exhaustive set of outcomes sum to one; apply the property that the probabilities of an exhaustive set of mutually exclusive events sum to one

  • An exhaustive set covers every possible outcome, so its probabilities have total 11.
  • Mutually exclusive events cannot occur together; for such events, add their probabilities to find the probability that any one occurs.
  • The complement rule is P(not A)=1P(A)P(\text{not }A)=1-P(A), which treats AA and not AA as an exhaustive, mutually exclusive pair.
  • Do not add probabilities directly when events can overlap; first separate the overlap or subtract it once using P(AB)=P(A)+P(B)P(AB)P(A\cup B)=P(A)+P(B)-P(A\cap B).

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. The probability that a parcel arrives early is 0.370.37. Work out the probability that it does not arrive early.[1 mark]

    Answer

    • 0.630.63

    Method: Early and not early are exhaustive and mutually exclusive, so use the complement: 10.37=0.631-0.37=0.63.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. A trial has four mutually exclusive outcomes A, B, C and D. Their probabilities are 0.280.28, 0.410.41, xx and 0.190.19 respectively. Work out xx.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • x=0.12x=0.12

    Method: The outcomes are exhaustive, so their probabilities sum to 11. Therefore x=1(0.28+0.41+0.19)=10.88=0.12x=1-(0.28+0.41+0.19)=1-0.88=0.12.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. For two events A and B, P(A)=0.58P(A)=0.58, P(B)=0.47P(B)=0.47 and P(AB)=0.21P(A\cap B)=0.21. Work out the probability that neither A nor B occurs.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • 0.160.16

    Method: Split the possibility space into mutually exclusive regions. The probability of ABA\cup B is 0.58+0.470.21=0.840.58+0.47-0.21=0.84, because the intersection was counted twice. Neither event is the complement of the union, so its probability is 10.84=0.161-0.84=0.16.

P5 · Understand that empirical unbiased samples tend towards theoretical probability distributions, with increasing sample size

  • An empirical distribution is built from observed relative frequencies, whereas a theoretical distribution is predicted from a probability model.
  • With unbiased, independent trials, increasing the sample size usually makes empirical proportions settle nearer their theoretical probabilities.
  • For a fair die, a large sample should give each score a relative frequency near 1/61/6, but exact equality is not required.
  • A larger sample reduces random variation but does not repair a biased sampling method or guarantee a closer result on every single run.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. A fair coin gives a relative frequency of heads of 0.640.64 after 2525 tosses. Explain what is likely to happen to the relative frequency as many more unbiased tosses are made.[1 mark]

    Answer

    • It is likely to move closer to the theoretical probability 0.50.5, although it need not do so after every extra toss.

    Method: Use the long-run tendency: for unbiased coin tosses the empirical proportion tends towards the theoretical probability 1/21/2 as the sample becomes large.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. A spinner is designed to land on green with probability 0.30.3. It lands on green 88 times in 2020 spins and 6363 times in 200200 spins. Compare the two empirical probabilities with the theoretical probability.[3 marks]

    Answer

    • For 2020 spins, the relative frequency is 0.40.4.
    • For 200200 spins, the relative frequency is 0.3150.315.
    • The larger sample gives the value closer to 0.30.3.

    Method: Calculate 8/20=0.48/20=0.4 and 63/200=0.31563/200=0.315. Their distances from 0.30.3 are 0.10.1 and 0.0150.015, so the empirical result from 200200 spins is closer to the theoretical probability.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. A fair die is tested. In the first 6060 rolls, a six appears 1616 times. After 600600 rolls in total, a six has appeared 108108 times. A student says the die must be biased because neither relative frequency equals 16\dfrac{1}{6}. Evaluate the student's claim.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • The relative frequencies are 16600.267\dfrac{16}{60}\approx0.267 and 108600=0.18\dfrac{108}{600}=0.18.
    • The theoretical probability is 160.167\dfrac{1}{6}\approx0.167.
    • The larger-sample result is closer to the theoretical value, and an exact match is not expected, so the evidence does not establish bias.

    Method: Compare each empirical probability with 1/61/6. The differences are about 0.1000.100 for the first 6060 rolls and 0.0130.013 after 600600 rolls. Random variation explains a non-zero difference, and the movement towards 1/61/6 as the sample grows is consistent with a fair die.

P6 · Enumerate sets and combinations of sets systematically, using tables, grids, Venn diagrams and tree diagrams

  • Systematic enumeration lists every permitted outcome once, using a consistent order so omissions and duplicates are visible.
  • Use a table or grid for two varying quantities, a tree for successive choices, and a Venn diagram for membership of overlapping sets.
  • For two sets, place the intersection first, then the parts belonging only to each set, and finally the values outside both sets.
  • Do not assume all listed outcomes are equally likely; enumeration identifies possibilities, while probability also depends on the model.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. A uniform is made from one of two shirts, blue or white, and one of three ties, red, silver or green. List all possible shirt-and-tie combinations.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • Blue-red, blue-silver, blue-green, white-red, white-silver, white-green.

    Method: Hold the shirt colour fixed and list every tie, then repeat for the other shirt. This gives 2×3=62\times3=6 combinations, each appearing once.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. The universal set is the integers from 11 to 2020. Set A contains the multiples of 33 and set B contains the factors of 1818. Enumerate the four regions of a Venn diagram for A and B.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • AB={3,6,9,18}A\cap B=\{3,6,9,18\}.
    • A only ={12,15}=\{12,15\}; B only ={1,2}=\{1,2\}.
    • Neither ={4,5,7,8,10,11,13,14,16,17,19,20}=\{4,5,7,8,10,11,13,14,16,17,19,20\}.

    Method: List A={3,6,9,12,15,18}A=\{3,6,9,12,15,18\} and B={1,2,3,6,9,18}B=\{1,2,3,6,9,18\}. Put their common values in the intersection, remove these to find each 'only' region, then place every unused integer from 11 to 2020 outside both circles.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. A three-digit number is formed from three different digits chosen from 11, 22, 33 and 44. Enumerate all the numbers that are greater than 230230 and even. How many of these numbers do not contain the digit 11?[4 marks]

    Answer

    • 234,312,314,324,342,412,432234,312,314,324,342,412,432.
    • 44 of these numbers do not contain the digit 11.

    Method: Work systematically by hundreds digit. Starting with 22 gives 234234; starting with 33 gives 312,314,324,342312,314,324,342; starting with 44 gives 412,432412,432. The values without digit 11 are 234,324,342,432234,324,342,432, so there are 44.

P7 · Construct theoretical possibility spaces for single and combined experiments with equally likely outcomes and use these to calculate theoretical probabilities

  • A possibility space displays every combined outcome, often as ordered pairs in a grid.
  • When all elementary outcomes are equally likely, probability is favourable outcomes divided by the total number of outcomes in the space.
  • For two fair choices with mm and nn outcomes, a complete rectangular space has mnmn ordered pairs before restrictions are applied.
  • Do not count unordered pairs when the experiment records a first and second result; (a,b)(a,b) and (b,a)(b,a) are different ordered outcomes unless the context says otherwise.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. A fair coin is tossed and a fair spinner labelled 11, 22, 33 is spun. Write the six outcomes as ordered pairs and find the probability of getting a head and an even number.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • (H,1),(H,2),(H,3),(T,1),(T,2),(T,3)(H,1),(H,2),(H,3),(T,1),(T,2),(T,3).
    • P(head and even)=16P(\text{head and even})=\dfrac{1}{6}.

    Method: Pair each coin result with each spinner result. Only (H,2)(H,2) satisfies both conditions, so one of the six equally likely outcomes is favourable.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Spinner A has equal sectors labelled 11, 22, 33. Spinner B has equal sectors labelled 11, 22, 33, 44. Construct a possibility space and find the probability that the two scores have a sum greater than 55.[3 marks]

    Answer

    • Possibility space: (1,1),(1,2),(1,3),(1,4),(2,1),(2,2),(2,3),(2,4),(3,1),(3,2),(3,3),(3,4)(1,1),(1,2),(1,3),(1,4),(2,1),(2,2),(2,3),(2,4),(3,1),(3,2),(3,3),(3,4).
    • The favourable ordered pairs are (2,4),(3,3),(3,4)(2,4),(3,3),(3,4).
    • P(sum greater than 5)=312=14P(\text{sum greater than }5)=\dfrac{3}{12}=\dfrac{1}{4}.

    Method: A 33 by 44 grid contains 1212 equally likely ordered pairs. Mark the entries whose sums exceed 55: 6,6,76,6,7 at (2,4),(3,3),(3,4)(2,4),(3,3),(3,4). Therefore the probability is 3/12=1/43/12=1/4.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. Two different cards are chosen in order from cards labelled 11, 22, 33, 44 and 66. The first card is the tens digit and the second is the units digit. Construct the theoretical possibility space and find the probability that the two-digit number is divisible by 33.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • Possibility space: 12,13,14,16,21,23,24,26,31,32,34,36,41,42,43,46,61,62,63,6412,13,14,16,21,23,24,26,31,32,34,36,41,42,43,46,61,62,63,64.
    • There are 5×4=205\times4=20 equally likely ordered outcomes.
    • The favourable numbers are 12,21,24,42,36,6312,21,24,42,36,63.
    • Probability =620=310=\dfrac{6}{20}=\dfrac{3}{10}.

    Method: Make a 55 by 55 grid and exclude its diagonal because the cards must be different. A number is divisible by 33 when its digit sum is divisible by 33. Testing the 2020 allowed ordered pairs gives the six listed numbers, so the probability is 6/20=3/106/20=3/10.

P8 · Calculate the probability of independent and dependent combined events, including using tree diagrams and other representations, and know the underlying assumptions

  • For events along one route through a tree, multiply branch probabilities; for alternative mutually exclusive routes, add their products.
  • Independent events leave later probabilities unchanged, while dependent events change later probabilities because earlier outcomes affect the situation.
  • Without replacement, update both numerator and denominator after each draw; with replacement, the original probabilities repeat.
  • Do not multiply probabilities without checking the assumptions: identical branch probabilities require independence or a replacement mechanism.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. A fair coin is tossed and an independent spinner lands on red with probability 35\dfrac{3}{5}. Work out the probability of a head and red.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • 310\dfrac{3}{10}

    Method: The events are independent, so multiply their probabilities: 12×35=310\dfrac{1}{2}\times\dfrac{3}{5}=\dfrac{3}{10}.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. A bag contains 44 blue counters and 33 amber counters. Two counters are chosen at random without replacement. Work out the probability that both counters are blue.[3 marks]

    Answer

    • 27\dfrac{2}{7}

    Method: The first blue probability is 4/74/7. After a blue is removed, 33 of the 66 remaining counters are blue. Multiply along the route: 47×36=1242=27\dfrac{4}{7}\times\dfrac{3}{6}=\dfrac{12}{42}=\dfrac{2}{7}.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. A bag contains 55 black and 33 white counters. Three counters are chosen at random without replacement. Work out the probability that exactly two are black. State why the branch probabilities change after each choice.[5 marks]

    Answer

    • P(exactly two black)=1528P(\text{exactly two black})=\dfrac{15}{28}.
    • The probabilities change because counters are not replaced, so the composition and total in the bag change.

    Method: There are three possible colour orders: BBW, BWB and WBB. Their probabilities are 58×47×36=528\dfrac{5}{8}\times\dfrac{4}{7}\times\dfrac{3}{6}=\dfrac{5}{28}, 58×37×46=528\dfrac{5}{8}\times\dfrac{3}{7}\times\dfrac{4}{6}=\dfrac{5}{28} and 38×57×46=528\dfrac{3}{8}\times\dfrac{5}{7}\times\dfrac{4}{6}=\dfrac{5}{28}. Add the mutually exclusive routes to get 15/2815/28.

P9 · Calculate and interpret conditional probabilities through representation using expected frequencies with two-way tables, tree diagrams and Venn diagrams [Higher only]

  • A conditional probability restricts the sample space to outcomes satisfying the stated condition.
  • In a two-way table or Venn diagram, calculate P(AB)P(A\mid B) by dividing the frequency in both AA and BB by the total frequency in BB.
  • Expected frequencies can replace probabilities on a tree; after multiplying each branch by a common starting total, condition using the relevant terminal frequencies.
  • Do not divide by the overall total when a condition is given: the denominator must be the frequency of the conditioning event.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. A two-way table records 6060 students. Of the 2424 who travel by bus, 99 arrive late. Find the probability that a randomly chosen bus traveller arrives late.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • P(latebus)=924=38P(\text{late}\mid\text{bus})=\dfrac{9}{24}=\dfrac{3}{8}

    Method: The condition restricts the group to the 2424 bus travellers. Of these, 99 are late, so divide 99 by 2424 and simplify.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Of 500500 expected customers, 60%60\% are members. Of the members, 70%70\% order online. Of the non-members, 35%35\% order online. Use expected frequencies to find the probability that an online customer is a member.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • P(memberonline)=34P(\text{member}\mid\text{online})=\dfrac{3}{4}

    Method: There are 0.60×500=3000.60\times500=300 members and 200200 non-members. Expected online frequencies are 0.70×300=2100.70\times300=210 members and 0.35×200=700.35\times200=70 non-members. Among 210+70=280210+70=280 online customers, 210210 are members, so the conditional probability is 210/280=3/4210/280=3/4.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. In an expected-frequency Venn diagram for 240240 people, 138138 are in set A, 102102 are in set B and 5454 are in both sets. A person is chosen from those who are in exactly one of the sets. Find the conditional probability that the person is in A.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • 711\dfrac{7}{11}

    Method: The A-only frequency is 13854=84138-54=84 and the B-only frequency is 10254=48102-54=48. Exactly one set contains 84+48=13284+48=132 people. Restricting to this group, the required probability is 84/132=7/1184/132=7/11.