4.6 Inheritance, variation and evolution — coverage pack

21 specification leaves · notes, questions, answers and worked methods

4.6.1.1 · Sexual and asexual reproduction

  • Sexual reproduction involves the fusion of male and female gametes: sperm and egg cells in animals, or pollen and egg cells in flowering plants.
  • Meiosis forms non-identical gametes, and mixing genetic information at fertilisation produces variation among the offspring.
  • Asexual reproduction involves one parent, no fusion of gametes and mitosis only, so the offspring are genetically identical clones.
  • Do not describe asexual offspring as merely similar: unless a mutation occurs, they are genetically identical to the parent and to one another.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. State two features of asexual reproduction.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • It involves one parent and no fusion of gametes.

    Method: Award one mark for one parent and one for no gamete fusion; mitosis only or genetically identical offspring are also valid features.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Compare the production and genetic features of offspring made by sexual and asexual reproduction.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • Sexual reproduction fuses male and female gametes made by meiosis and mixes genetic information, producing varied offspring. Asexual reproduction uses one parent and mitosis with no gamete fusion, producing genetically identical clones.

    Method: Give paired comparisons: gamete fusion versus none, meiosis versus mitosis, two parental gametes versus one parent, and varied versus genetically identical offspring.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. A plant can produce seeds after pollination and can also produce new plants from runners. Explain why the offspring from these two methods differ genetically.[5 marks]

    Answer

    • Seed production is sexual: meiosis forms gametes, pollen and egg nuclei fuse, and genetic information mixes, so the offspring vary. Runner production is asexual: one parent produces new plants by mitosis without gamete fusion, so they are clones.

    Method: Identify seeds as sexual and runners as asexual, then link meiosis and fertilisation to mixed genetic information and link mitosis without fertilisation to genetically identical offspring.

4.6.1.2 · Meiosis

  • Cells in reproductive organs divide by meiosis to form gametes with a single set of chromosomes.
  • Before meiosis the genetic information is copied, then the cell divides twice to produce four genetically different gametes.
  • At fertilisation two gametes join and restore the normal chromosome number; the new cell then grows by mitosis and its cells differentiate during embryo development.
  • The detailed named stages of meiosis are not required, but the chromosome number must be described as halved in gametes and restored at fertilisation.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. State the type of cell division that produces gametes and the number of gametes produced from one cell.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • Meiosis produces four gametes.

    Method: Recall that a reproductive cell divides twice during meiosis, giving four products.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Explain how meiosis and fertilisation maintain the chromosome number from one generation to the next.[3 marks]

    Answer

    • Meiosis halves the chromosome number to make gametes with one set. At fertilisation, two gametes fuse, restoring the normal number with two sets of chromosomes.

    Method: Follow chromosome number rather than naming meiosis stages: halving occurs during gamete formation and fusion restores the full number.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. Describe the sequence from one cell in a reproductive organ to a differentiated embryo, including the divisions involved and the genetic relationship between cells.[6 marks]

    Answer

    • Genetic information is copied and meiosis divides the cell twice to make four genetically different gametes with single chromosome sets. Two gametes fuse at fertilisation, restoring the normal number. The fertilised cell divides repeatedly by mitosis, increasing cell number, and cells then differentiate.

    Method: Sequence six ideas: DNA copied, two meiotic divisions, four non-identical haploid gametes, fertilisation, mitotic growth and differentiation.

4.6.1.3 · Advantages and disadvantages of sexual and asexual reproduction (biology only)

  • In separate biology, sexual reproduction creates variation, so natural selection may favour some offspring if the environment changes, and humans can exploit variation in selective breeding.
  • Asexual reproduction needs only one parent, avoids the time and energy needed to find a mate, is faster and can produce many identical offspring in favourable conditions.
  • Some organisms use both methods: malarial parasites reproduce asexually in humans and sexually in mosquitoes, while fungi and plants can also switch between sexual and asexual reproduction.
  • Neither method is always best: clones can be highly successful in stable conditions but shared susceptibility becomes a disadvantage if conditions change or a disease appears.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. State one advantage of sexual reproduction and one advantage of asexual reproduction.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • Sexual reproduction produces variation; asexual reproduction needs only one parent.

    Method: Give one distinct benefit for each method. Other valid asexual benefits include speed, energy efficiency and many offspring in favourable conditions.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. A fungus reproduces rapidly by asexual spores when conditions are stable but sometimes reproduces sexually. Explain the advantage of each strategy.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • Asexual reproduction is fast, needs no mate and produces many successful clones in favourable conditions. Sexual reproduction produces genetic variation, so some offspring may survive a change in conditions and be selected.

    Method: Link the stable environment to efficient cloning, then link sexual reproduction to variation and a survival advantage under environmental change.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. Evaluate whether a farmer should propagate a disease-resistant crop asexually or continue sexual breeding. Use benefits and risks of both methods.[6 marks]

    Answer

    • Asexual propagation rapidly produces many identical plants that retain the resistant characteristic and needs one parent. However, low genetic variation could make the whole crop vulnerable to a new disease or environmental change. Sexual breeding is slower and may not preserve the exact combination, but variation supplies material for selection and future adaptation. The choice depends on how stable the conditions and disease threats are.

    Method: Balance rapid retention of a useful genotype against clone vulnerability, then balance the cost of sexual reproduction against the protective value of variation before giving a conditional judgement.

4.6.1.4 · DNA and the genome

  • DNA is a polymer made of two strands forming a double helix, and chromosomes are structures containing DNA in the nucleus.
  • A gene is a small section of DNA on a chromosome that codes for a particular amino-acid sequence and therefore a specific protein.
  • The genome is the entire genetic material of an organism.
  • Studying the human genome can help find genes linked to disease, improve understanding and treatment of inherited disorders, and trace past human migration patterns.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. Define the genome of an organism.[1 mark]

    Answer

    • The genome is the entire genetic material of the organism.

    Method: The definition must refer to all, or the entire set, of the organism's genetic material.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Describe the relationship between DNA, chromosomes, genes and proteins.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • Chromosomes contain DNA. A gene is a small section of DNA on a chromosome. Its base information codes for a particular sequence of amino acids, which forms a specific protein.

    Method: Build the hierarchy from chromosome to DNA to gene, then connect the gene's code to amino-acid order and a protein.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. Explain three medical or historical benefits of studying the whole human genome, and state one limitation when predicting disease.[5 marks]

    Answer

    • Genome study can identify genes linked to diseases, support understanding and treatment of inherited disorders, and help trace past human migration. A disease association does not guarantee that a person will develop the disease because other genes or environmental factors may also influence phenotype.

    Method: Credit the three specification uses separately. The limitation should distinguish a gene link from certainty, using interaction with other genetic or environmental factors.

4.6.1.5 · DNA structure (biology only)

  • In separate biology, DNA is a polymer of repeating nucleotide units, and each nucleotide contains a common sugar, a phosphate group and one base.
  • The four DNA bases are A, C, G and T, with one base attached to each sugar in the strand.
  • The long DNA strands have alternating sugar and phosphate sections, while the order of the attached bases stores genetic information.
  • A sequence of three bases codes for a particular amino acid, so the order of bases controls the amino-acid order in a protein; do not say that one base codes for one amino acid.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. Name the three components of a DNA nucleotide.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • A sugar, a phosphate group and one base.

    Method: List the common sugar and phosphate components and the variable base component.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Describe the structure of a DNA strand and explain how it can carry different genetic information.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • A DNA strand is a polymer of repeating nucleotides with alternating sugar and phosphate sections. Each sugar has one of the bases A, C, G or T attached, and different base orders carry different information.

    Method: Describe the repeating nucleotide polymer, the sugar-phosphate arrangement, attachment of one of four bases and variation in base sequence.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. Higher tier: A mutation changes the order of bases in a gene. Explain how this may change the protein made, using the relationship between bases and amino acids.[5 marks]

    Answer

    • Each sequence of three bases codes for a particular amino acid. Changing the base order may change a three-base code, so a different amino acid may be placed in the chain. This changes the amino-acid sequence and may alter the protein's structure or function, although some mutations have no effect on phenotype.

    Method: Trace the causal chain from altered base sequence to a possible altered triplet, amino acid, amino-acid sequence and protein; retain 'may' because not every mutation changes phenotype.

4.6.1.6 · Genetic inheritance

  • An allele is a form of a gene; genotype is the combination of alleles present, while phenotype is the expressed characteristic produced through the genotype's molecular effects.
  • A dominant allele is expressed with one or two copies, whereas a recessive allele is expressed only when two copies are present and no dominant allele is present.
  • An organism is homozygous when its two alleles for a gene are the same and heterozygous when they differ; most characteristics involve several interacting genes rather than one gene.
  • Higher tier: construct Punnett-square genetic crosses and use probability, simple ratios and family-tree evidence to predict single-gene inheritance, remembering that probability does not guarantee an individual outcome.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. Define the terms allele and heterozygous.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • An allele is a form of a gene; heterozygous means having two different alleles for that gene.

    Method: Give the precise gene-level definition for allele and contrast the two alleles in a heterozygous genotype.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. In mice, black fur allele B is dominant to white fur allele b. Explain the phenotypes of mice with genotypes BB, Bb and bb.[3 marks]

    Answer

    • BB and Bb mice have black fur; bb mice have white fur because the recessive phenotype is expressed only with two recessive alleles.

    Method: Apply dominance to each genotype: any genotype containing B expresses black, while bb contains no dominant allele and expresses white.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. Higher tier: Two heterozygous black mice, Bb and Bb, are crossed. Construct the genetic cross and predict the genotype ratio, phenotype ratio and probability of a white offspring.[6 marks]

    Answer

    • Gametes are B and b from each parent; offspring genotypes are BB, Bb, Bb and bb; genotype ratio is 1 BB : 2 Bb : 1 bb; phenotype ratio is 3 black : 1 white; probability of white is 1/41/4.

    Method: Place B and b gametes from each parent around a Punnett square, combine them in four boxes, count genotypes, then use dominance to count phenotypes. One of four boxes is bb, so the probability is 1/41/4.

4.6.1.7 · Inherited disorders

  • Inherited disorders result from inheriting particular alleles; polydactyly is caused by a dominant allele, while cystic fibrosis is caused by a recessive allele.
  • A person with one cystic-fibrosis allele and one unaffected allele is a carrier: they do not have the disorder but can pass the recessive allele to offspring.
  • Embryo screening can identify embryos carrying alleles linked to inherited disorders before implantation.
  • Judgements about embryo screening should balance reduced suffering and treatment costs against financial cost, possible errors, embryo rejection and ethical or social objections.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. State which disorder is caused by a dominant allele and which is caused by a recessive allele: polydactyly and cystic fibrosis.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • Polydactyly is dominant; cystic fibrosis is recessive.

    Method: Match each named disorder to the inheritance pattern specified by AQA.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Two parents do not have cystic fibrosis, but each carries its recessive allele. Explain how they can have a child with the disorder.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • Each parent is heterozygous and has an unaffected dominant allele, so neither shows the disorder. Each can pass on the recessive allele. A child inheriting the recessive allele from both parents is homozygous recessive and has cystic fibrosis.

    Method: Explain the parents' carrier phenotypes, inheritance of one allele from each and expression only in the homozygous recessive child.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. Evaluate the use of embryo screening by parents who risk passing on a serious inherited disorder.[6 marks]

    Answer

    • Screening may allow selection of embryos without the disorder, reducing suffering and future medical costs and helping parents make informed choices. It is expensive, may give uncertain or erroneous results, and unused embryos may be rejected or destroyed. Some people object on ethical or religious grounds or fear selection for non-medical traits. A judgement depends on disorder severity, test reliability and the family's values.

    Method: Develop at least two benefits and two economic, social or ethical concerns, then make a reasoned conclusion tied to the information rather than asserting that screening is always right or wrong.

4.6.1.8 · Sex determination

  • Ordinary human body cells contain 2323 pairs of chromosomes: 2222 pairs of non-sex chromosomes and one pair of sex chromosomes.
  • Females usually have XX sex chromosomes, while males usually have XY sex chromosomes.
  • Egg cells carry an X chromosome, whereas sperm cells carry either X or Y, so the sperm chromosome determines XX or XY in the offspring.
  • Each fertilisation is an independent probability event, so the sex of earlier children does not change the probability for the next child.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. State the sex-chromosome combination usually found in females and in males.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • Females are XX and males are XY.

    Method: Recall the two standard sex-chromosome combinations.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Use a genetic cross to explain why the probability of an XX child is 1/21/2.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • The mother produces only X eggs; the father produces X and Y sperm. The combinations are XX and XY in equal numbers, so two of four Punnett-square outcomes are XX and the probability is 1/21/2.

    Method: Cross maternal gametes X and X with paternal gametes X and Y. The four boxes are XX, XY, XX and XY, giving two XX outcomes out of four.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. A family has three XY children. A parent claims that the next child is now more likely to be XX. Evaluate the claim using chromosome inheritance and probability.[5 marks]

    Answer

    • The claim is incorrect. Every egg carries X, while a fertilising sperm can carry X or Y. Each fertilisation is independent, so previous outcomes do not alter the next cross and the probability of XX remains 1/21/2.

    Method: Identify the sex chromosome in each gamete, derive the equal XX and XY outcomes, and apply independence rather than trying to balance the previous births.

4.6.2.1 · Variation

  • Variation means differences in characteristics among individuals in a population, caused by inherited genes, environmental conditions or their interaction.
  • There is usually extensive genetic variation within a population of one species, and all genetic variants arise through mutations.
  • Mutations occur continuously: most do not affect phenotype, some influence it and very few determine it.
  • A rare mutation can produce a new phenotype which, if suited to an environmental change, may contribute to relatively rapid change in a species; mutation is not caused because an organism needs it.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. State the three broad causes of variation in phenotype.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • Genetic causes, environmental causes, and interaction between genes and the environment.

    Method: List inherited differences, conditions during development, and their combined effect.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Explain why genetically identical plant cuttings can grow to different heights in two gardens.[3 marks]

    Answer

    • The cuttings have the same inherited genes, but environmental conditions such as light, water, mineral availability or temperature differ. The genome interacts with these conditions during development, producing different phenotypes.

    Method: Recognise the cuttings as clones, identify relevant environmental differences and link gene-environment interaction to height phenotype.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. A pesticide is introduced into an insect population. Explain how a rare mutation may contribute to a rapid population change without the pesticide causing the useful mutation.[5 marks]

    Answer

    • Mutations arise continuously and at random before or during exposure. A rare mutation may give a phenotype that survives the pesticide. Those insects reproduce and pass the variant allele to offspring, so its frequency rises under selection. The pesticide selects existing variation rather than directing insects to mutate.

    Method: Separate mutation from selection: random variation appears first, the changed environment creates differential survival, inheritance and reproduction then change allele frequency.

4.6.2.2 · Evolution

  • Evolution is a change in the inherited characteristics of a population over time through natural selection and may result in a new species.
  • Natural selection acts on inherited variation: individuals with phenotypes better suited to the environment are more likely to survive and reproduce.
  • Advantageous alleles are passed to offspring and become more common over generations, changing the population rather than changing an individual during its lifetime.
  • Two populations have formed different species when they have become so different that they can no longer interbreed to produce fertile offspring; all living species ultimately evolved from simple life forms over more than three billion years.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. Define evolution.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • Evolution is a change in the inherited characteristics of a population over time.

    Method: Include inherited characteristics, a population and change over time.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Explain how natural selection can make a favourable inherited characteristic more common in a population.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • Individuals vary genetically. Those with a favourable phenotype are more likely to survive and reproduce in that environment. They pass the advantageous allele to offspring, so over generations the allele and characteristic become more common.

    Method: Use the sequence variation, differential survival, successful reproduction, inheritance and increasing frequency over generations.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. Two populations descended from one species now differ strongly in phenotype. Explain what further evidence would show that speciation has occurred, and how natural selection could have produced the differences.[6 marks]

    Answer

    • Speciation is shown if members of the two populations can no longer interbreed to produce fertile offspring. Different environments select different inherited variants; better-suited individuals survive and reproduce, pass on their alleles and make them more frequent. Accumulated inherited differences can eventually produce reproductive isolation.

    Method: Do not use appearance alone as the species test. State the fertile-offspring criterion, then trace divergent selection in each environment to accumulated inherited differences and loss of successful interbreeding.

4.6.2.3 · Selective breeding

  • Selective breeding, or artificial selection, is human breeding of plants or animals for chosen genetic characteristics.
  • Choose parents with the desired characteristic, breed them, select the best offspring and repeat the process over many generations until the desired characteristic is common.
  • Useful targets include disease-resistant crops, increased meat or milk production, gentle domestic animals and large or unusual flowers.
  • Repeated breeding among selected relatives reduces genetic variation and can cause inbreeding, increasing susceptibility to disease or inherited defects.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. Define selective breeding.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • Humans breed plants or animals for particular desired genetic characteristics.

    Method: Include deliberate human choice and a desired inherited characteristic.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Describe how a breeder could develop a variety of crop in which most plants resist a fungal disease.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • Choose resistant parents from a mixed population and breed them. Select resistant offspring and breed those together. Repeat this selection and breeding over many generations until most or all offspring show resistance.

    Method: State parent selection, breeding, offspring selection and repetition across generations, keeping the target characteristic genetic.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. Evaluate a programme that selectively breeds dairy cattle only from the highest-milk-producing animals.[5 marks]

    Answer

    • Milk yield may increase over generations and improve food production. However, using a small selected group can cause inbreeding and reduce genetic variation, making inherited defects or disease susceptibility more common. The programme should also monitor health and maintain genetic diversity rather than selecting yield alone.

    Method: Explain the intended benefit, connect repeated narrow selection to inbreeding and reduced variation, identify biological consequences and give a balanced judgement.

4.6.2.4 · Genetic engineering

  • Genetic engineering modifies an organism's genome by introducing a gene from another organism to give a desired characteristic.
  • Engineered crops may resist disease, insect attack or herbicides and may give increased yields, while engineered bacteria can produce human insulin.
  • Potential concerns include effects on wild-flower and insect populations, incompletely explored health effects and ethical objections, while medical research explores genetic modification for inherited disorders.
  • Higher tier: enzymes isolate the required gene, the gene is inserted into a vector such as a bacterial plasmid or virus, and the vector transfers it into target cells early in development.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. Define genetic engineering.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • It is modification of an organism's genome by introducing a gene from another organism to give a desired characteristic.

    Method: Include genome modification, transfer of a gene from another organism and the desired characteristic.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Evaluate the use of a genetically modified crop that resists insect attack.[5 marks]

    Answer

    • The crop may suffer less damage, need less insecticide and produce a higher yield. However, the modified gene or farming practice may affect wild plants and insect populations, resistant pests could be selected, and some people have health or ethical concerns. Use should depend on evidence from testing and monitoring.

    Method: Develop agricultural benefits and ecological or social risks, then make a conclusion based on evidence rather than treating GM crops as automatically safe or harmful.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. Higher tier: Describe how a human gene can be transferred into bacterial cells so that the bacteria develop the desired characteristic.[6 marks]

    Answer

    • Use enzymes to isolate the required human gene. Insert the gene into a vector, usually a bacterial plasmid or a virus. Use the vector to insert the gene into bacterial cells at an early stage, then grow the modified cells so they express the desired characteristic and reproduce.

    Method: Give the ordered stages: isolate with enzymes, place in a vector, transfer into the required cells early in development, then allow the engineered cells to develop and multiply.

4.6.2.5 · Cloning (biology only)

  • In separate biology, tissue culture grows identical plants from small groups of plant cells, while cuttings produce identical plants by a simpler established method.
  • Embryo transplants involve splitting cells from an early animal embryo before they specialise and placing the identical embryos into host mothers.
  • In adult cell cloning, an unfertilised egg has its nucleus removed, receives a nucleus from an adult body cell and is stimulated by an electric shock to divide.
  • The cloned embryo is placed in a womb after becoming a ball of cells and carries the adult nucleus's genetic information; it is not genetically identical to the host mother.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. State one use of plant tissue culture and explain why the new plants are clones.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • It can preserve rare plant species or produce plants commercially; the new plants contain the same genetic information because they grow from cells of one parent plant.

    Method: Give one specified use and connect asexual growth from one source plant to genetic identity.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Describe how embryo transplants produce several genetically identical farm animals.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • Allow an animal embryo to begin developing, split its cells before they specialise, form identical embryos and transplant them into host mothers to continue development.

    Method: The key order is early embryo, separation before specialisation, identical embryos and transfer to host mothers.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. Describe adult cell cloning from an unfertilised egg cell to the birth of a cloned animal, and identify which animal supplies most of the clone's genetic information.[6 marks]

    Answer

    • Remove the egg nucleus and insert a nucleus from an adult body cell. Apply an electric shock so the cell divides into an embryo. When it is a ball of cells, implant it into a host mother's womb for development. Most genetic information comes from the adult nucleus donor, not the egg or host mother.

    Method: Sequence enucleation, nuclear transfer, electric stimulation, embryo division and implantation, then trace the nuclear DNA to the adult body-cell donor.

4.6.3.1 · Theory of evolution (biology only)

  • In separate biology, Darwin used observations from a worldwide expedition, experiments, discussion and developing geological and fossil evidence to propose evolution by natural selection.
  • Darwin's explanation was that individuals vary, those best suited to the environment survive and breed more successfully, and their advantageous characteristics pass to the next generation.
  • Acceptance was slow because the theory challenged religious ideas, evidence was initially limited, and the mechanisms of inheritance and variation were not then understood.
  • Lamarck proposed that changes acquired during an organism's lifetime could be inherited, but this does not occur in the vast majority of cases; Darwin's book was published in 18591859.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. State two reasons why many people did not immediately accept Darwin's explanation of how species change.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • It challenged ideas that God created all species, evidence was limited, and inheritance and variation were not understood.

    Method: Select any two of the three reasons specified by AQA.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Describe Darwin's explanation of evolution by natural selection.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • Individuals in a species show variation. Those with characteristics better suited to the environment are more likely to survive and breed. They pass the advantageous characteristics to offspring, so these become more common over generations.

    Method: Use the linked sequence of variation, environmental advantage, differential survival and reproduction, inheritance and population change.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. Compare Darwin's and Lamarck's explanations for a population becoming better suited to its environment, and explain why Darwin's theory became accepted.[6 marks]

    Answer

    • Darwin proposed pre-existing variation and natural selection: better-suited individuals reproduce and pass inherited characteristics to offspring. Lamarck proposed that changes acquired through use or during life were inherited. Genetic inheritance, fossils and other accumulating evidence support Darwin's mechanism, whereas acquired characteristics are not inherited in the vast majority of cases.

    Method: Contrast selection of inherited variation with inheritance of acquired changes, then connect later evidence and understanding of genes to acceptance of Darwin's explanation.

4.6.3.2 · Speciation (biology only)

  • In separate biology, Alfred Russel Wallace independently proposed evolution by natural selection and published joint writings with Darwin in 18581858.
  • The joint publication prompted Darwin to publish On the Origin of Species in 18591859, and their ideas transformed biology by providing a natural explanation for adaptation and diversity.
  • Wallace gathered worldwide evidence and is especially associated with warning colouration and pioneering work on speciation, which later evidence refined.
  • Speciation can occur when populations become isolated, face different selection pressures, accumulate different inherited changes and eventually cannot interbreed to produce fertile offspring.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. State one contribution made by Alfred Russel Wallace to evolutionary biology.[1 mark]

    Answer

    • He independently proposed evolution by natural selection, gathered evidence, or pioneered work on speciation or warning colouration.

    Method: Give one contribution explicitly associated with Wallace in the specification.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Describe how the work of Wallace affected the development and publication of evolutionary theory.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • Wallace independently developed natural selection from worldwide evidence. He and Darwin published joint writings in 18581858, prompting Darwin to publish On the Origin of Species in 18591859. Wallace's work on warning colouration and speciation added evidence and ideas that influenced biology.

    Method: Identify independent development, joint publication, its effect on Darwin's publication and Wallace's evidence or specialist contribution.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. A physical barrier separates two populations of one species into different environments. Explain the steps by which two new species may arise.[6 marks]

    Answer

    • Isolation prevents gene flow between the populations. Mutation and existing genetic variation provide different variants. Different environments favour different phenotypes, so natural selection changes allele frequencies differently. Inherited differences accumulate over many generations until the populations can no longer interbreed to produce fertile offspring, forming new species.

    Method: Follow isolation through variation, different selection pressures, differential reproduction, inherited divergence and finally reproductive isolation using the fertile-offspring criterion.

4.6.3.3 · The understanding of genetics (biology only)

  • In separate biology, Mendel's mid-1919th-century plant breeding experiments suggested that inherited characteristics are controlled by units passed unchanged to descendants.
  • Mendel's work was not recognised during his lifetime because genes, chromosomes and the mechanisms of inheritance were not yet understood and his findings were not widely appreciated.
  • Later observations showed that chromosomes during cell division behaved like Mendel's units, leading scientists to propose that genes are located on chromosomes.
  • Determining DNA structure and gene function in the mid-2020th century added further evidence, so modern gene theory developed through the work of many scientists over time.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. State the main conclusion Mendel drew from his plant breeding experiments.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • Characteristics are determined by inherited units that are passed to descendants unchanged.

    Method: Use Mendel's historical 'units' idea and their unchanged transmission between generations.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Explain how observations of chromosomes helped scientists connect Mendel's units with genes.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • Scientists observed chromosome behaviour during cell division. Chromosomes and Mendel's inherited units behaved in similar ways, leading to the idea that the units, now called genes, are located on chromosomes.

    Method: Link the later cell-division observation to similar inheritance behaviour and then to the chromosome location hypothesis for genes.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. Describe how understanding of genetics developed from Mendel's experiments to modern gene theory, and explain why this is an example of science developing over time.[6 marks]

    Answer

    • Mendel proposed inherited units from plant crosses in the mid-1919th century, but their basis was unknown. Later chromosome observations showed similar behaviour, suggesting that genes lie on chromosomes. In the mid-2020th century DNA structure and gene function were worked out. Evidence and explanations from many scientists accumulated and linked together, producing gene theory.

    Method: Give the events in chronological order and explain that later technologies, observations and contributions supplied evidence that connected and refined earlier ideas.

4.6.3.4 · Evidence for evolution

  • The theory of evolution by natural selection is widely accepted because multiple independent lines of evidence support it.
  • Genetics shows that inherited characteristics pass to offspring in genes, providing the inheritance mechanism missing when Darwin first proposed his theory.
  • The fossil record shows organisms changing through Earth's history and allows relationships and sequences of change to be inferred.
  • Antibiotic resistance evolving in bacterial populations provides directly observable evidence of variation, selection, inheritance and population change.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. State two sources of evidence for evolution.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • Fossils and the evolution of antibiotic resistance in bacteria.

    Method: Name the two evidence sources required explicitly by this specification point.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Explain how modern genetics strengthened the evidence for Darwin's theory.[3 marks]

    Answer

    • Genetics showed that characteristics are passed from parents to offspring in genes. This supplied a mechanism for inheritance of advantageous variation, which was unknown when Darwin published his theory.

    Method: Connect genes to inherited characteristics and explain why that connection fills a historical gap in natural selection.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. Explain why fossil evidence and antibiotic resistance together provide stronger support for evolution than either source alone.[5 marks]

    Answer

    • Fossils record long-term changes and relationships among organisms through geological time. Antibiotic resistance shows natural selection occurring over short timescales in living bacterial populations. Both fit inheritance through genes, so independent historical and observable evidence converge on the same evolutionary explanation.

    Method: Distinguish the timescale and nature of each source, show how each supports population change, and explain that agreement between independent evidence increases confidence.

4.6.3.5 · Fossils

  • Fossils are remains or traces of organisms from millions of years ago that are found in rocks.
  • They may form when decay conditions are absent, when organism parts are replaced by minerals during decay, or when traces such as footprints, burrows and rootlet marks are preserved.
  • The fossil record is incomplete because many early organisms were soft-bodied and left few traces, while geological activity destroyed many traces that did form.
  • Fossils and evolutionary trees can show how much organisms have changed over time, but gaps mean scientists cannot be certain how life began on Earth.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. State two ways in which a fossil may form.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • Decay may be prevented, organism parts may be replaced by minerals, or a trace such as a footprint may be preserved.

    Method: Give any two distinct formation routes from the specification.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Explain why the fossil record gives an incomplete account of the earliest life on Earth.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • Many early organisms were soft-bodied, so they decayed without leaving fossils. Fossilisation requires particular conditions, and geological activity has destroyed many traces. Therefore much evidence is missing and scientists cannot reconstruct the beginning of life with certainty.

    Method: Link soft bodies and rare preservation to few original fossils, add destruction by geology, and conclude that gaps limit certainty.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. An evolutionary tree places species P and Q on branches that share a more recent common branch point than either shares with species R. Interpret this evidence and state one reason the proposed tree could later change.[5 marks]

    Answer

    • P and Q are inferred to be more closely related and to share a more recent common ancestor than either does with R. The tree is a scientific interpretation based on current classification and fossil data; a newly discovered fossil or improved evidence about structures or chemistry could change the proposed relationships.

    Method: Read relatedness from the most recent shared branch point, then recognise the tree as an evidence-based model that can be revised when data improve.

4.6.3.6 · Extinction

  • A species is extinct when no individuals of that species remain alive.
  • Extinction can follow environmental change that is too rapid or severe for the population to adapt through natural selection.
  • Possible contributing factors include new predators, competitors or diseases, habitat loss, catastrophic events and failure to reproduce successfully.
  • A species becoming rare or disappearing from one locality is not necessarily extinction, because living individuals may remain elsewhere.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. Define extinction.[1 mark]

    Answer

    • Extinction occurs when no living individuals of a species remain.

    Method: The definition must cover the entire species, not one habitat or population.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Describe three factors that may contribute to the extinction of a species.[3 marks]

    Answer

    • Examples include environmental change, habitat loss, a new predator, a new competitor, a new disease, a catastrophic event or failure to reproduce.

    Method: Give three biologically distinct pressures capable of reducing survival or reproduction until no individuals remain.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. A small island species loses most of its habitat while a new predator and disease arrive. Explain why this combination creates a high risk of extinction.[5 marks]

    Answer

    • Habitat loss reduces food, shelter and breeding sites, so population size falls. Predation increases deaths and disease lowers survival or reproduction. A small population contains fewer potential mates and may have low genetic variation, so it is less likely to contain variants suited to rapid change. The interacting pressures may reduce the population to zero.

    Method: Link each factor to survival or reproduction, explain why small population size limits recovery or adaptation, and connect the combined effects to no remaining individuals.

4.6.3.7 · Resistant bacteria

  • Bacteria evolve rapidly because they reproduce quickly, and mutations can produce new strains including antibiotic-resistant variants.
  • An antibiotic kills susceptible bacteria, while resistant bacteria survive, reproduce and pass resistance on, so the resistant strain becomes more common and spreads.
  • MRSA is antibiotic resistant, and resistant infections are difficult to treat because people may lack immunity and effective antibiotics may be unavailable.
  • Resistance develops more slowly when antibiotics are not used for viral or non-serious infections, patients complete prescribed courses and agricultural use is restricted; developing new antibiotics is slow and costly.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. State why bacterial populations can evolve antibiotic resistance rapidly.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • Bacteria reproduce rapidly and mutations can produce resistant strains.

    Method: Link short generation time to repeated reproduction and recognise mutation as the source of resistant variants.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Explain how treating a mixed bacterial population with an antibiotic can increase the proportion of resistant bacteria.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • A mutation has produced some resistant bacteria. The antibiotic kills susceptible bacteria but resistant ones survive. Survivors reproduce and pass on resistance, so the resistant strain forms a larger proportion of the population.

    Method: Describe pre-existing variation, selection by the antibiotic, survival, reproduction and inheritance; do not say the antibiotic deliberately makes bacteria resistant.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. Evaluate three measures intended to slow the emergence and spread of antibiotic-resistant bacterial strains.[6 marks]

    Answer

    • Avoid prescribing antibiotics for viral or non-serious infections so unnecessary selection is reduced. Patients should complete prescribed courses so surviving bacteria are less likely to remain and reproduce. Restrict agricultural use to reduce selection and spread outside medicine. These measures slow resistance but cannot stop mutations, while replacement antibiotics are costly and slow to develop.

    Method: For each measure, explain how it reduces antibiotic exposure or survival and reproduction of resistant strains, then recognise the limitation that mutation continues and new-drug development may not keep pace.

4.6.4 · Classification of living organisms

  • Linnaeus classified organisms by structure and characteristics into kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus and species.
  • The binomial naming system gives each organism a two-part name consisting of its genus and species.
  • Improved microscopes, knowledge of internal structures and biochemical evidence led scientists to revise classification and to Woese's three domains: archaea, bacteria and eukaryota.
  • Evolutionary trees use current classification evidence for living organisms and fossil data for extinct organisms to show proposed relationships, so they may change when evidence improves.

Tier 1 · Easy

  1. 1. State the two taxonomic groups used in a binomial name.[2 marks]

    Answer

    • Genus and species.

    Method: A binomial contains the genus name followed by the species name.

Tier 2 · Standard

  1. 1. Explain why biological classification systems have changed since Linnaeus developed his system.[4 marks]

    Answer

    • Improved microscopes revealed more internal structures, and better understanding of biochemical processes and chemical analysis supplied new evidence. Scientists used this evidence to revise relationships and propose new models such as Woese's three-domain system.

    Method: Name developments in evidence or technology, state that they revealed previously unavailable similarities and differences, and link this to revised models.

Tier 3 · Hard

  1. 1. Compare Linnaean classification, the three-domain system and evolutionary trees as ways of organising biological evidence.[6 marks]

    Answer

    • Linnaeus grouped organisms by structure and characteristics in the hierarchy kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus and species. Woese used chemical evidence to divide life into archaea, bacteria and eukaryota. Evolutionary trees display proposed relatedness using classification data for living organisms and fossils for extinct organisms. All are evidence-based models and can be revised as evidence improves.

    Method: Give the basis and organisation of each system, distinguish the three domains from the Linnaean hierarchy, explain the relational purpose of a tree and finish with the effect of new evidence.